The Accidental Cheesecake Company

About Us

Welcome to The Accidental Cheesecake Company, a delightful bakery nestled in Bowling Green, MO, that has been serving the surrounding areas since 2024. We specialize in crafting delicious cheesecakes, cupcakes, cookies, brownies, and more. At The Accidental Cheesecake Company, we are dedicated to creating sweet treats that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.
In addition to our delicious baked goods, we also offer catering services to make your special events even more memorable. We proudly hold a manufacturing license and retail sales certification, which means you can purchase our products for resale. We also provide items for schools, making it easy to share our treats with students and staff.
Come visit us and experience a slice of sweetness at The Accidental Cheesecake Company!

Areas Served

Our Professional Associations

Chamber of Commerce

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Special Occasion Desserts
Cheesecakes and Cupcakes

Our Services include:

Custom Flavors: We love bringing your ideas to life. Whether you’re dreaming of a classic favorite or something completely unique, we’ll create any custom flavor for your special-order dessert. From rich and indulgent to bright and fruity, your perfect flavor is just a request away.
Handmade With Fresh Ingredients: Every dessert we make is crafted by hand using fresh, high-quality ingredients. No shortcuts, no mixes — just real, homemade goodness in every bite. From your first slice to the last crumb, you’ll taste the care and craftsmanship that goes into our work.
Sugar-Free & Gluten-Free Options: Everyone deserves something sweet. That’s why we offer sugar-free and gluten-free versions of many of our desserts. Each item is thoughtfully made to ensure amazing flavor and texture, so guests with dietary needs never feel like they’re settling for less.
Cheesecakes, Cakes, Cupcakes & Cookies: From silky cheesecakes and elegant cakes to playful cupcakes and fresh-baked cookies, we offer desserts for every taste and every occasion. Each piece is handmade, beautifully crafted, and customizable to fit your theme, flavor preference, or celebration style.
Catering Services: Make your next event unforgettable with our dessert catering. Whether you’re hosting a corporate gathering, family celebration, holiday party, or community event, we provide beautifully made desserts that taste just as amazing as they look. With delivery available and a wide variety of menu options, sweetening your celebration has never been easier.
Wedding Catering & Desserts: Your wedding deserves something extraordinary. Our wedding dessert services include custom cakes, dessert tables, guest favors, and beautifully crafted treats designed to match your vision. Whether your style is classic, modern, romantic, or whimsical, we create elegant desserts that are as delicious as they are stunning. From intimate ceremonies to grand celebrations, we’re here to make every sweet detail unforgettable.

Our Products include:

Cheesecakes
Cupcakes
Cookies
Brownies
Coffee Drinks
Juices
Soft Drinks
Sugar-Free Cookies
Gluten-Free Treats
Custom Cakes
Sheet Cakes
Round Cakes
Cream Horns
Cream Cakes
Tiramisu
Pies

Testimonials

On 2/13/2026 Cheryl Wagner had this to say:
Lovely little bakery! Everything is made in house and from scratch. The people running it were both amazing. I got the Lemon cheesecake and the red velvet tres leches cake and they were absolutely delicious! I will be back to try more goodies! The deserts were perfectly sweetened and not too sweet or too tart. Everything was pleasant about this business!

On 2/12/2026 Carletta Sutton had this to say:
There is a wide variety of cupcakes, brownies, cookies, and cheesecakes. I didn't really care for cupcakes until I tried the wedding cake cupcakes. The cake was unbelievably tender and moist and tasted just like a wedding cake or maybe better. The sweets are always made fresh and different flavors are sometimes added throughout the day tempting you to come back again the same day. The owner is friendly and helpful; able to provide a detailed description of her products. There isn't any seating but you can get in out quickly in the lare afternoon but you run the risk of her selling out of your favorite treat. The taste, quality, variety, appearance, and freshness makes this the place you want to get a treat for your child, spouse, or yourself. Prices are very reasonable.

On 2/5/2026 Amanda Davis had this to say:
I am from out of town but I was in need of some baked goods for a work event. I was blown away with the flavors, the textures and the prices. So affordable and top notch in all areas. A MUST for your baked goods

On 2/4/2026 Kassy Wille had this to say:
I went in one morning and got a variety box of cupcakes for a coworkers birthday and the cupcakes were all very fresh and delicious!!! I went back that same day to get more for my family!!!

On 11/23/2025 Jennifer Black had this to say:
These are the best cupcakes I've ever have eaten! This is not an exaggeration. The sweets are top tier and the owner was such a lovely lady. She told us the story of how her bakery came to be and the atmosphere is adorable. Highly recommend!!! The cinnamon roll cupcake and marble brownie are spectacular!

Contact Us

The Accidental Cheesecake Company
519 W Main St Bowling Green, MO 63334
Phone: (573) 666-2671
Email: accidentalcheesecakes@gmail.com

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, PayPal, Visa, Venmo, Cash App

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 7:30 AM - 4:30 PM
Wednesday: 7:30 AM - 4:30 PM
Friday: 7:30 AM - 4:30 PM

News

💍✨ Now Booking Weddings for 2026! ✨💍
Planning your big day? The Accidental Cheesecake Company is now booking wedding dates — and we offer so much more than just cheesecake!
From elegant dessert tables to custom wedding cakes, mini dessert assortments, and beautifully curated sweet displays, we create treats that fit your style, theme, and vision.
Whether you want:
🍰 A stunning wedding cake
🍫 Dessert bars & tables
🧁 Custom mini desserts
🍓 Signature creations your guests will love
—we’re here to make your wedding unforgettable and delicious.
📅 Now booking for the upcoming wedding season!
Our calendar fills fast, so reserve your date early.
📲 Message us today to start planning your perfect wedding desserts!

Info

FAQ

What kind of baked goods do you offer?

We specialize in cheesecakes, but also offer cupcakes, cookies, brownies and other sweet treats.

Where are you located and what are your hours?

We’re at 519 W Main St., Bowling Green, MO 63334. For hours, please check our website or call us at (573) 666-2671.

Do you accept walk-ins or is everything by order only?

We welcome walk-ins for available items, but for larger or special-flavor orders we recommend placing an order ahead of time.

Do you provide catering services?

Yes — we offer catering for special events to help make your gathering more memorable.

How far in advance should I place an order for a custom cheesecake?

For custom flavors, sizes or event catering, we recommend at least 48-72 hours in advance. If you have a larger event (wedding, corporate), please contact us as early as possible to secure your date.

What if I don’t see the flavor I want?

Give us a call! If it’s not on the menu, we can likely make it for you.

Site Navigation